I want to begin with Jill Bolte Taylor and the experience
she encountered after having a stroke. Though it may have been an extremely
traumatic time in her life she describes it almost blissfully as if she enjoyed
the silence that was the effects of the stroke. The picture she paints is a
kind of “lala” land, which if it were my own experience, would seem incredible.
I could imagine it as feeling innocent again, like a young child, not knowing
what is right and wrong. The story about Ildefonso, however, is very much the
opposite of Jill Bolte Taylor and in a way makes her sound somewhat
unappreciative of what she has had the majority of her life. It’s amazing that
after not having language half his life, Ildefonso could no longer contemplate
or imagine not having it. I don’t believe it was necessary for him per say
based on the idea there are other ways to communicate without language. Having
language is just a matter of association, like putting a name with a face. His ability
to think did not depend on his adaption to our language, because from what she described
about his friends they had already adapted their own way to communicate with
each other which tells me that they could indeed think for themselves. I don’t think
learning our language was necessarily a good thing nor a bad thing, it only
opened eyes to a more in depth way of communicating and approaching life.
I feel like I can relate to Anzaldua in the sense that I too
consider myself a mixture of different cultures. I have constantly moved from
region to region since I was a young child and gained various traits that have
become part of who I am from the different places I’ve lived. I actually
consider myself somewhat of a chameleon because of my ability to relate to
different people in different social groups. As I’ve gotten older I have become
very well rounded and able to incorporate all the different sides of me no
matter who I am around. As far as Anzaldua’s claim that denying a group their
language is a violation of their rights, I completely agree. The first
amendment was put into place for a reason and not only that but no one should
be denied the right to be different. Some children make up secret languages amongst
there friends that make no sense at all but are deemed “silly” and “child-like”
but they are not shunned for them. I wouldn’t go as far as to say it is an act
of violence but it is extremely unjust and unfair.
No comments:
Post a Comment